Quantcast

The Cheese Stands Alone

Notes from Inside

Tags

No tags have been created or used yet.

Sponsored Links

My Favorite Blogs

    The Chicken or the Egg?

    The local school district is currently in the process of adopting an attendance policy that would allow 10 absences and then require a doctor's note in order for an illness to be excused.

    Administrators presented the proposal last month, then revised it in a school board work session last Wednesday to account for suggestions that parents raised in a series of public forums. The revision eased some restrictions but retained the 10-day limit and left intact some points parents had disputed.

    Still in place are rules that would make family travel unexcused for a student past the 10-day limit and a possibility that, in some cases, a school secretary's evaluation of a child's health could outweigh a parent's opinion. (Sioux Falls Argus Leader Nov. 13)

    This is an ongoing problem in many school districts.  While I would like to believe that all children in attendance WILL learn and that any child who does not attend will NOT learn, I'm afraid that just isn't true.  I think it is more true in elementary school that chronic absence will affect learning.  However, for high school students I am afraid that the truth is that students who are not successful in school miss more school than those who are successful.  This makes me wonder if poor attendance causes low grades or do low grades cause poor attendance. 

    Many studies look at students' grade point averages and determine that students with better attendance records have better grades, and students with poor attendance have poor grades.  Therefore, we conclude that improving attendance will improve grades.  However, I think many students do not care about attending school because they feel hopeless, and keeping them in the classroom more than likely will not change that.  While attendance is without a doubt an important factor, I believe other measures need to be taken to improve grades.  I believe the ultimate truth is that once again NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND is driving this policy.  Once again we have to do what is best for the policy, not what is best for the students!!!

    Posted: Tuesday, November 13, 2007 10:08 AM by SHart

    Comments

    MysteryTeacher said:

    We are developing a strict policy in our district too.  We have a lot of parents who keep their kids home (in 4th grade even) to babysit while they go do other things.  We are only half way through the second quarter and I have one child who has missed 10 days.  Her grades are not so hot either.  They never bother to make up the work.  I don't follow them around to ask for it either.  I remind them when they come in to make up the work but they never do.  They think that if they are absent, it is an excused assignment.  Their parents do too.  One parent said, "How can you expect my child to do that assignment when they weren't here for the lesson."  I told her that was why it was so important for her to be there or to make up the assignment when she returned.  I am confused...is an absence just a day off for these people?

    # November 13, 2007 10:24 PM

    Betty said:

    I have had parents who wanted make up work immediately and brought sick kids to school in the morning to collect the work. The poor kids would be standing there with a fever and asking for work for the day.   Then, there are those who miss school repeatedly and don't ask for make up work.  To them, it is just time off from school.  I was sick a lot as a kid and frequently had to miss school.  My parents always made sure that I had the help I needed to stay up with the class.  It's all about the home environment.  On a separate note, I don't like it when parents purposely send their kids to school sick.  They expose everyone else and really should stay at home.

    # November 14, 2007 2:31 PM

    jtspencer said:

    I think that we need to think completely outside the box when it comes to reaching the "ditchers."  Where is their voice in this process?  I have yet to see a study regarding why students don't show up.  Is it bullying?  Is it that they hate school?  Is it a failure of the system to make education meaningful?  Is it simply laziness?  

    From there, schools need to be innovative.  Some students, for example, would thrive in a smaller environement or in online learning. Others need a mentor or a small group to hold them accountable.

    # November 18, 2007 6:19 AM
    New Comments to this post are disabled.